The Private Engagement That’s Eating Away at KPIs
From the very beginning, large multi-client marketing agencies and small one-woman-show social media managers alike could report on performance by reading off a dashboard of likes, comments, shares and click-through rates. That dashboard is still very much alive and important, but, as things tend to do, the social media landscape has grown more complicated. Those metrics alone no longer tell the full story.
Social Media Engagement Is Moving Behind the Scenes
Anyone who has recently tried to find a recipe being advertised on Instagram understands. Instead of a clickable link in the creator’s Story, we’re now faced with the multi-step process of sending a message, potentially providing an email address and then clicking the link from within our DMs. Actions like these put more weight on saves, shares and DMs than the on-post engagement metrics that the industry is used to concentrating on.
But this kind of action also complicates the attribution funnel that marketers are used to tracking. When a link is clicked within a DM rather than through a traditional “link in bio,” standard post-level attribution can become fragmented. For this reason, over the last year or so, Third Street Digital has leaned into prioritizing engagement rate, a percentage that measures how actively audiences interact with content as a whole.
The Rise of Zero-Click Marketing and Dark Social
Beyond newer prioritized metrics, there is plenty of meaningful activity sneaking past KPIs altogether. Consider every time someone takes a screenshot during a Reel to capture an ingredient list. Or maybe a screenshot of a post is used for a Google product search or sent in a group chat. Actions like these are difficult, if not impossible, for marketers to track and attribute back to the original content.
Enter the era of zero-click marketing and dark social: where content can influence awareness, consideration and even purchasing behavior without producing a clean, trackable click.
On the surface, this could appear to be a dip or plateau in engagement when, in actuality, it may be because the tools used to measure this kind of consumer behavior haven’t fully caught up.
Looking Beyond Traditional Social Media KPIs
On the marketing side, it just takes a little more creativity, flexibility and reflection in reporting. Combining classic on-post engagement metrics with tools like social listening, alongside indicators such as website traffic spikes, branded search volume, brand sentiment and share of voice, can help paint a bigger picture.
At Third Street, this looks like a multi-product approach for social media clients to better understand whether their content is resonating positively and creating the desired impact, which can look different for every brand.
A More Complete View of Social Media Performance
The “click” isn’t dead. And if we’ve learned anything over the last couple of years, it’s that things will inevitably shift sooner rather than later. But the brands moving with the flow and taking a broader view of social media performance are the ones building a more complete understanding of their audiences.